Saturday, 20 April 2013

"And the burnt Fool's bandaged finger goes wabbling back to the Fire"

The Late 2000's Financial Crisis (which started about 2007 and is ongoing) accomplished one highly unlikely end, among others: it got me reading business and economic news reports. I wanted to learn, first, how we got into this mess; second, how bad was it going to get; and, third, once I had a good sense of answers to the first two matters, when are the bankers going to go to jail. At least, when would they be kicked out. Or resign. Preferably with an admission of guilt and an appropriate apology.

It has happened here and there. Iceland put the self-important scoundrels in jail, nationalized the banks, and repudiated unreasonable debt and debt payable in foreign currency. It recovered well. Britain's response has been less clear-cut. Bob Diamond, the head of Barclay's Bank, who saw no need to apologize or resign, was forced out. The Royal Bank of Scotland has been effectively nationalized, so a continuing stream of embarrassing stories has not been covered up by the board and management. There has been a parliamentary inquiry and a promise of new rules. On the other hand, Britain's going to court now, defending its right to remain unaffected by the Eurozone's new Financial Transaction Tax (FTT). This is despite two-thirds of British citizens supporting some form of FTT. The United States, though, has the honour of being the most deeply corrupted nation in terms of banker influence on policy. The banks at the heart of the Financial Crisis kept their management and received a trillion dollar loan. The bill to keep the same flawed activities from creating a new financial crisis (The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act) was fiercely resisted, especially the Volcker Rule section, which was blown hither and yon before it was passed.

All this is prequel to the story I want to link to now. According to the Financial Post, the same risky behaviour that created the last financial crisis has re-emerged. The key quotation is, "The Dodd-Frank regulatory overhaul is forcing banks to take extra steps in the process of bundling loans, but it does not change the basic approach."

The quotation that provides the title for this post is from Kipling's poem "The Gods of the Copybook Headings."
As it will be in the future, it was at the birth of Man
There are only four things certain since Social Progress began.
That the Dog returns to his Vomit and the Sow returns to her Mire,
And the burnt Fool's bandaged finger goes wabbling back to the Fire;
  ...

----------------------

Update: An article on Rolling Stone, "Everything is Rigged: The Biggest Price-Fixing Scam Ever" by Matt Taibbi, explains that the price-fixing scandal over Libor in Britain is matched by a similar one in the US called USDAfix, which includes some of the same criminal players plus a few different ones. The problem extends beyond interest rates:
"In all the over-the-counter markets, you don't really have pricing except by a bunch of guys getting together," Masters notes glumly.
That includes the markets for gold (where prices are set by five banks in a Libor-ish teleconferencing process that, ironically, was created in part by N M Rothschild & Sons) and silver (whose price is set by just three banks), as well as benchmark rates in numerous other commodities – jet fuel, diesel, electric power, coal, you name it. The problem in each of these markets is the same: We all have to rely upon the honesty of companies like Barclays (already caught and fined $453 million for rigging Libor) or JPMorgan Chase (paid a $228 million settlement for rigging municipal-bond auctions) or UBS (fined a collective $1.66 billion for both muni-bond rigging and Libor manipulation) to faithfully report the real prices of things like interest rates, swaps, currencies and commodities.
All of these benchmarks based on voluntary reporting are now being looked at by regulators around the world, and God knows what they'll find. The European Federation of Financial Services Users wrote in an official EU survey last summer that all of these systems are ripe targets for manipulation. "In general," it wrote, "those markets which are based on non-attested, voluntary submission of data from agents whose benefits depend on such benchmarks are especially vulnerable of market abuse and distortion."

Sunday, 14 April 2013

Coincidence or Conspiracy? Ship Classifications.

Some facts are so odd that they simply cannot be coincidence. Except that they have no rational reason for being implemented by plan. A prime example is ship classifications. I set out to list them in order of size, from largest to smallest.
  1. Aircraft carrier
  2. Battleship
  3. Cruiser
  4. Destroyer
  5. (Destroyer) Escort
  6. Frigate
There you go, listed by size. Surely the fact that they are also in alphabetical order is a coincidence! Surely it can't be!

Wednesday, 10 April 2013

What Would Korean War II Be Like?

Fire in the Hole

The latest news is that South Korea expects that North Korea will test a ballistic missile on April 15, the birthday of Kim Il-Sung, the country's first and "eternal" president. This is not the first: it is part of a long-term program of rocket development. Two of the launches were identified as satellite launches, but the rockets could as easily be used as ballistic missiles. Their accuracy is not high enough to reliably destroy military or civilian targets with conventional explosives in the warhead. They would be more dangerous if and when North Korea miniaturizes its atomic weapons enough to mount on the missiles. Alternatively, they could be used with other non-conventional weapons: specifically, chemical or biological weapons. Both are as illegal as heck in most civilized states, but few doubt that North Korea would scruple to use them. In fact,
Pyongyang unilaterally withdrew from the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) in January 2003 and is not a party to the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty (CTBT) or a member of the Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR). The DPRK is not a party to the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC), and is believed to possess a large chemical weapons program. North Korea is a party to the Biological and Toxin Weapons Convention (BTWC), but is suspected of maintaining an offensive biological weapons program in defiance of that treaty.
A moment to clarify terms for the weapons we are talking about. The press and politicians are fond of tossing around the acronym WMD, meaning "Weapons of Mass Destruction," for atomic, biological, and chemical weapons. I had previously known of these by the more logical acronym ABC. A little research told me that the proper term now is CBRNe.
In English the term CBRN is a replacement for the cold war term NBC (nuclear, biological, and chemical), which had replaced the term ABC (atomic, biological, and chemical) that was used in the fifties. The addition of the R (for radiological) is a consequence of the "new" threat of a radiological weapon (also known as "dirty bombs"). In the new millennium, the term CBRNe was introduced as an extension of CBRN - the e in this term representing the enhanced (improvised) explosives threat.
Who knew that my acronyms were a full half-century out of date?

A missile test now represents a greater danger of escalation towards war than any previous missile test. South Korea was stung by two North Korean provocations in 2010--the sinking of the ROKS Cheonan and the shelling of Yeongpyeong Island--and declared that any further provocation would be met with force instead of forbearance. South Korean destroyers will monitor and American ones could shoot down a North Korean missile that threatens to hit South Korea. The United States has placed another anti-missile defence to protect its base in Guam. In addition, Japan has deployed anti-missile systems to use on any missile that overflies its territory. However, we do not know what North Korea's response would be if one of its missiles were shot down. It would, undoubtedly, feel that it had to respond, and that response could provoke an additional response from its neighbours. The result could conceivably be a spiral towards war, as the UN Secretary General, Ban Ki-Moon, has warned.

The question this posting tries to answer is "What would that war be like?"

If War Occurs

The main weapons that North Korea possesses are conventional, and often either old or old-fashioned. It has a 1.1 million man army, 3000 tanks, a large artillery force, substantial special forces within the army, and a large number of hardened, dug-in military sites that would not be trivial to destroy. With these weapons, the North Koreans could, if they felt they must, shell the South Korean capital of Seoul, launch a full assault on South Korea, and create widespread terror and chaos behind the South Korean and American defensive line.

Shelling Seoul

In 1994 and again in 2013, North Korean spokesmen threatened to turn Seoul into a "sea of fire." Its potential to do so is often accepted as fact. North Korea has, in fact, 10,000, 11,000, or 12,000 artillery pieces within range of Seoul. (The number differs according to the source). The counter battery effort--identifying the location of the North Korean artillery and destroying it with missiles, bombs, drones, and self-propelled howitzer rounds would quickly reduce its effectiveness. According to a Chinese article, the American government has announced that it would use the B61 "bunker buster" bomb (a tactical nuclear weapon) if necessary. Despite all this, the first hours would be brutal, and several thousand people in Seoul would die.

The Main Assault

The American and Korean Operational Plan for an invasion is called OPLAN 5027. It is regularly updated. For example, before 1973, OPLAN involved a retreat to a line behind the Han River, which would be held until reinforcements allowed a counterattack. That implies giving up half of Seoul to North Korean occupation.



More recently, due to a reassessment of the strength of the North and South Korean militaries, the plan is to hold a line north of Seoul while striking North Korea itself with the far superior American and South Korean naval and air forces. Again, the eventual counterattack could take Pyongyang and, potentially, all of North Korea. The ability to do this depends on several factors.
First, the ROK forces must be able to withstand DPRK forces over the first 5-15 days. Second, they must hold the line while US and ROK forces are mustered for the counteroffensive for another 15-20 days. Such a campaign also entails CFC air forces controlling the air and neutralizing DPRK attacks against southern airbases, as well as successful aerial interdiction of DPRK ground force movements.
The geography of Korea requires that a second Korean War have similar elements and objectives as the first one. It could also have the same result. In the first, North Korea was defeated but the Chinese took over the war when the UN forces reached the Chinese border (the Yalu River). Keeping the Chinese from entering the war would be a primary objective of diplomacy this time.

Although few people outside of North Korea give the North Korean blitzkrieg much chance of success, it is fascinating to read a North Korean opinion on the matter.

Special Forces

The North Koreans have 180,000 special forces soldiers. To put this in perspective, the American Special Operations Command has 63,000. Even if this number were only half of the total of the American special forces, it would still be far short of North Korea's. Knowing the weaknesses of its army in a direct assault, it has developed the largest special forces in the world. Their job would include attacks on people, infrastructure, and special buildings to create terror and disruption. The number who could get behind the main battle lines is substantial: "Estimates reveal that the North Koreans can deliver over 7,000 SOF personnel to each of South Korea's coastlines." This is in addition to whatever number may be delivered by air or infiltrate the South Korean and American lines. We can assume that the special forces would kill many people directly or indirectly, as by the destruction of dams.

Aftermath of War

 If North Korea managed to delay a total military defeat, it might try to negotiate terms of peace. China would certainly support this. The United States and, especially, South Korea, might not. There is no way to predict the results.

Complicating things would be North Korea's small nuclear deterrent. If it survived the war (because taking it out early on would be an American priority), it could still be used as a threat. How credible the threat would be is another matter, since the North Koreans do not, yet, have a credible way to drop an atomic weapon on their enemies. Could they try a suicide option--for example, threatening to blow up the population of their own capital if enemy troops enter it? If the North Korean regime did this, could it survive against its own army and people? There is no way to predict the results.

However, there is a set of South Korean and American options, called OPLAN 5029, to guide the response to a collapse of the North Korean regime. The Chinese may have their own plans in place against that eventuality. If those plans conflict, there is no way to predict the results.

You can follow the developments in the 2013 Korean Crisis on a handy Wikipedia page.

--------------------------------
Update 15 April 2013. The US Army War College recently wargamed approaches to "securing"  North Korean atomic assets. The takeaway:
In the end it takes the U.S. a force of 90,000 troops and 56 days to secure "North Brownland's" nuclear weapons.
"We are not very well prepared to deal with a collapsed North Korea," said Bruce Bennett, a defense analyst at the RAND Corporation.
On the good side, I like the cut of their jib when it comes to moving civilians out of the cities that they intend to enter.
U.S .troops, he said, had immediate problems surging into the North Korea-like country. V-22 Ospreys zoomed U.S. soldiers deep beyond the border, but with reinforcements so far behind they were quickly surrounded by the enemy and needed to be pulled out. American troops eventually made it over the border, but with nuclear sites located in populated areas, their mission became more difficult. U.S. forces made humanitarian aid drops to draw people out of the cities.
 It was also interesting to read the characterization of the land in these war games as "a family regime that had nuclear weapons." Now where did I read the phrase "family atomics" before?

Monday, 8 April 2013

Flatland and Planiversal Machines

It is amazing how certain things make an lasting, even an indelible, impression. For example, when Edwin Abbott Abbot (sic) wrote Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions in 1884, he could not have imagined that his satire taking place in a two-dimensional universe would inspire a feature film in 2007. I couldn't, but here it is, all the same.


Just as unlikely, but equally true, there is another film called Flatland, also inspired by the same book, and released in the same year. Here's the trailer.


You can read the original book at Project Gutenberg here and a lovely digitized copy of the original publication on the Internet Archive here.

I caught the bug at third hand. In the July 1980 edition of Scientific American, Martin Gardner published an article that included the most wondrous two-dimensional machines: lock and key combinations, steam engines, and more. One could look at the diagram and comprehend the entire operation of the machine. Since the wonderful internet has provided me with so many seemingly lost treasures, I went searching for that article and found it. It is called "The Wonders of a Planiverse."

The article was, in fact, the review of a 98-page monograph called  Two-Dimensional Science and Technology. published in 1979 by A.K. Dewdney, a professor of Computer Science at the University of Western Ontario. His home page is here. Gardner's review exercised the same fascination on many others as it had on me: over two-thousand letters and comments reached Dewdney. As a result, he edited A Symposium on Two-Dimensional Science and Technology, which came out in 1981; The Second Symposium on Two-dimensional Science and Technology, in 1986; and a novel, The Planiverse, in 1986.

Let us have a look at a couple of the machines that captured my attention. They are comprised of just a few building blocks that would work as well in a two-dimensional space as a three-dimensional one.

To make a faucet, combine them like this.

To make a steam engine, combine them like this.


As Dewdney writes, and Gardner quotes,
It is amusing to think that the rather exotic design pressures created by the planiversal environment could cause us to think about mechanisms in such a different way that entirely novel solutions to old problems arise. The resulting designs, if steriversally practical, are invariably space-saving.
This is true, but they might not be as easily manufactured. An addendum to Gardner's article gives a letter from John S. Harris, of Brigham Young University's English Department, who points out that one famous engineer did design two-dimensionally.
As I examined Alexander Keewatin Dewdney's planiversal devices in Martin Gardner's article o n science and technology in a two-dimensional universe, I was struck with the similarity of the mechanisms to the lockwork of the Mauser military pistol of 1895. This remarkable automatic pistol (which had many later variants) had no pivot pins or screws in its functional parts. Its entire operation was through sliding cam surfaces and two-dimensional sockets (called hinges by Dewdney). Indeed, the lockwork of a great many firearms, particularly those of the 19th century, follows essentially planiversal principles. For examples see the cutaway drawings in Book of Pistols and Revolvers by W. H . B. Smith. 
Gardner suggests an exhibit of machines cut from cardboard, and that is exactly how the firearms genius John Browning worked. He would sketch the parts of a gun on paper or cardboard, cut out the individual parts with scissors (he often carried a small pair in his vest pocket), and then would say to his brother Ed, "Make me a part like this." Ed would ask, "How thick, John?" John would show a dimension with his thumb and forefinger, and Ed would measure the distance with calipers and make the part. The result is that virtually every part of the 100 or so Browning designs is essentially a two-dimensional shape with an added thickness. 
This planiversality of Browning designs is the reason for the obsolescence of most of them. Dewdney says in his enthusiasm for the planiverse that "such devices are invariably space-saving." They are also expensive to manufacture. The Browning designs had to be manufactured by profiling machines: cam-following vertical milling machines. In cost of manufacture such designs cannot compete with designs that can be produced by automatic screw-cutting lathes, by broaching machines, by stamping, or by investment casting. Thus although the Browning designs have a marvelous aesthetic appeal, and although they function with delightful smoothness, they have nearly all gone out of production. They simply got too expensive to make.
Three-D printers may help to change that.

Monday, 1 April 2013

Propaganda Picture

The CBC web site recently published a set of recent North Korean propaganda photographs. They show Kim Jong-Un surrounded by attentive people and, usually, pointing at something. When one sees them all together, of course, it is remarkable how much pointing-at-things he seems to do.

Anyway, one of the pictures made me laugh.


Here is Kim Jong-Un at a military base pointing...at a guitar. A guitar. A serious-looking senior military officer takes notes. (Excuse the pun).

Thursday, 28 March 2013

Some Thoughts on Nietzsche

A student of mine (I was tutoring him as he studied Political Science) was assigned Nietzsche's On the Genealogy of Morality, so I had to read it through as well. As I usually do, before reading the work itself, I read through the book's introduction and then read more background on the work and the author from the web. I was aware that Nietzche's thoughts were criticized strongly while he was alive and were then damned after his death for a presumed association with Nazi thought. (His sister supported the Nazis). I had read an interesting argument that the evil mastermind in the Sherlock Holmes stories, Professor Moriarty, was based on Nietzche. (The book, which I enjoyed but have misplaced is Naked is the Best Disguise by Samuel Rosenberg). On the other hand, I had read a sympathetic treatment of the man and his philosophy in Alain de Botton's The Consolations of Philosophy. The academic consensus, also, seemed admiring.

As I read On the Genealogy of Morality, I took notes, then revised them into the following. Page numbers refer to the Carol Diethe translation, edited by Keith Ansell-Pearson, Revised Student Edition (2007) in the "Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought" series.
--------------------------------------------------------------------  
On reading Nietzsche for the first time, I came to understand that much of his writing is not what it seems. What seems original is largely commonplace; what seems heartfelt is fantasy; what seems logical is emotion. These observations relate, respectively, to his theories of the creation of society, his theories of morality, and the relationship between his theories and his actions.

First in importance to the study of political science is his attack on Social Contract Theory and his presentation of an alternative. In the "Second Essay of On the Genealogy of Morality," he argues that society did not begin with a contract between free individuals, but as an “act of violence” perpetrated upon those individuals by a few strong-willed, aggressive people who are “organized for war.” The few take power over an unorganized mass of individuals. They impose a ruthless and wantonly cruel dictatorship that is the first form of state. From the dictatorship comes division of labour and the fruits of civilization.

The social contract theories of Hobbes or Locke could be regarded as thought experiments that may not have their roots in any prehistoric reality; it does not really matter for the theories if an actual formal agreement ever occurred. Nietzsche’s theory, however, is clearly meant to reflect a historical reality. He gives away the time and place and actors in this drama of conquest when he calls the ruling class “a pack of blond beasts of prey” and “a conqueror and master race.”  (p. 58, see also p. 23)

They can be no other than the original light-skinned, light-haired Aryans, the original speakers of Indo-European languages. In Nietzsche’s time they were popularly conceived as having conquered their way from their original home (or Urheimat) through all of Europe and most of Asia, subjugating or exterminating the original inhabitants of these regions. Far from being an original conception, Nietzsche here gives us a cliché.

Nevertheless, Nietzsche states that this cliché destroys the social contract theory. He says, “I think I have dispensed with the fantasy which has it begin with a ‘contract’. Whoever can command, whoever is a ‘master’ by nature, whoever appears violent in deed and gesture--what is he going to care about contracts!” (p. 58)

As that quotation implies, Nietzsche is here perpetuating another cliché of nineteenth-century thought: the Great Man Theory. The theory is that history is not created by laws of change or mass movements, but by the actions of a few exceptional men. Nietzsche describes such men in terms that Thomas Carlyle, the theory’s originator, might have praised. “Such beings cannot be reckoned with, they come like fate, without cause, reason, consideration or pretext, they appear just like lightning appears, too terrible, too sudden, convincing and ‘other’ even to be hated.” (p. 58) The difference between Carlyle’s Great Man and Nietzsche’s, however, is that the first crop up unpredictably while the latter occur in packs of blond beasts. In other words, in the context of early European history, the Aryans are Great Men, and the Great Men are Aryans.

And what of the personalities and beliefs of the subordinate classes, the non-Aryans, and even the “semi-animals” that the Great Men rule? Nietzsche explains them in the First Essay: “to all intents and purposes the subject race has ended up by regaining the upper hand in skin colour, shortness of forehead and perhaps even in intellectual and social instincts.” By social instincts he refers to the type of social organization preferred by the pre-Aryans. Specifically: “who can give any guarantee that modern democracy, the even more modern anarchism, and indeed that predeliction for the ‘commune’, the most primitive form of social structure...are not in essence a huge throw-back--and that the conquering master race, that of the Aryans, is not physiologically being defeated as well?” (p. 15)

Nietzsche presents these two cliches together, the Migration Theory and the Great Man Theory, as his theory of the origin of civilization. They win him no prize for original thought. From an early twenty-first century perspective, they run into additional obstacles. First, there is archaeology, which is by no means sure of whether Indo-Europeans spread out or the Indo-European languages did, and whether the spread was by fire and sword, trading and mating, or by seed and plough. More importantly, there is a problem with biology. There is no evidence that any personality trait, let alone a cultural one, is associated with a race and is diluted over time by miscegenation.

Nietzsche’s theories of morality are much more original than those he presents about society’s origins. They are founded on the observation that many languages use the same term to mean “morally good” and “socially superior.” (p. 13) His examples come from German, Iranian, and so on, but the English word noble makes his point just as well. Thus, he argues that the activities and attitudes of the noble class were considered good by definition. These include, towards each other, “consideration, self-control, delicacy, loyalty, pride, and friendship.” Towards outsiders, they include psychopathy: nobles “compensate for the tension which is caused by being closed in and fenced in by the peace of the community for so long, they return to the innocent conscience of the wild beast, as exultant monsters, who perhaps go away having committed a hideous succession of murder, arson, rape and torture, in a mood of bravado and spiritual equilibrium as though they had simply played a student’s prank, convinced that poets will now have something to sing about and celebrate for quite some time.” (p. 23)

This prelapsarian state of murderous grace was revealed to Nietzsche through his study of history. In the barbarian culture of Homer but also in the Classical culture of Athens he finds that a “good man” was not necessarily a “nice man,” but closer to the opposite. Pericles himself, says Nietzsche, praises Athenians’ “unconcern and scorn for safety, body, life, comfort, their shocking cheerfulness and depth of delight in all destruction, in all the debauches of victory and cruelty.” (p. 23) Nietzsche  found the same characteristics in Romans and Arabs, Germans and Japanese nobility. The morals of these peoples he calls “noble morality.” It values physical strength, health, beauty; it lacks fear, guilt, and pity; together, these characteristics make for happiness. Those who lack them are called either “the unhappy” or “the bad.” (Nietzsche does not use this example, but consider that the word for a poor farmer, low on the social scale, was “villain”).

Now consider how many of the characteristics of noble morality Nietzsche personally possesses, or even seeks to possess. There is no evidence that he ever committed any “hideous succession of murder, arson, rape, and torture,” however much he wished that he could. I find no evidence that he lacked conscience. He was clever, as the Jews were clever. He was introspective, as the Jews were introspective. He possessed resentment. He certainly possessed pity. Although he could write, “Are you going to woman? Forget not your whip,” his first stay at an insane asylum came when he rushed to save a horse from being whipped.

I suspect that, like a poor person imagining that he is rich or an unattractive person longing to be glamorous, Nietzsche created the “blond beast” as a wish fulfilment fantasy. The blond beast, muscled and amoral, is the exact opposite of a philosopher.

In the same way as the philosopher Nietzsche despised philosophers such as himself, the German Nietzsche despised Germans such as himself. He distanced himself from his origins with another fantasy, that he was the pure-blood descendant of Poles, and not merely Poles, but Polish nobles. Is it too much to see this fantasy as related to the blond beast fantasy? Polish nobles had dominated serfs much more recently than their German counterparts, and so were nearer to being authentic blond beasts.

Despite his reputation as an important thinker, Nietzsche reminds me of no-one more than Miniver Cheevy, the title character of an E.A. Robinson poem. Its second stanza introduces the blond beasts.
Miniver loved the days of old                      
When swords were bright and steeds were prancing;                      
The vision of a warrior bold                      
Would set him dancing.
The third stanza introduces Nietzsche’s Classical studies and his early work on Homer.
Miniver sighed for what was not,                          
And dreamed, and rested from his labors;                  
He dreamed of Thebes and Camelot,                  
And Priam's neighbors.
The fifth praises the "noble morality" that Nietzsche prefers to Jewish and Christian morality.
Minever loved the Medici,                          
Albeit he had never seen one;                      
He would have sinned incessantly                          
Could he have been one.
The sixth introduces Nietzsche’s loathing for the bourgeois culture of modern times.
Miniver cursed the commonplace                              
And eyed a khaki suit with loathing;                          
He missed the mediæval grace                      
Of iron clothing.                     
The final two verses reveal Nietzsche’s reactions to his circumstances. The first reaction, of course, was to philosophize.
Miniver scorned the gold he sought,                              
But sore annoyed was he without it;                          
Miniver thought, and thought, and thought,                      
And thought about it.
And the second reaction was to indulge in self-destructive behaviour.
Miniver Cheevy, born too late,                          
Scratched his head and kept on thinking;                  
Miniver coughed, and called it fate,                      
And kept on drinking.

Tuesday, 19 March 2013

More on Gun Control in the States

My previous article on gun control in the United States ended with doubt that effective control could be imposed. One obstacle is the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution which states, "A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." However, it is only the federal government that is prevented from infringing the right to bear arms. The individual States can infringe all they want, up to the point of eliminating that "right" completely. If one does, that's a matter between the State government and its voters.

Update: I was wrong here. Forty-four state constitutions have an equivalent to the Second Amendment. The same article says, "As well, the Supreme Court of the United States has held that the protections of the Second Amendment apply against state governments and their political subdivisions (see: McDonald v. Chicago)."

The voters are the other obstacle to gun control. Many argue that "guns don't kill people," so guns should not be regulated. That ignores the point that many other objects that can deliberately or accidentally injure or kill people are festooned with regulations about who can use them (cars, for example, must not be driven by uninsured nor unlicensed nor intoxicated people) and where (i.e. on roads) and how (e.g. at or below the posted speed limit) whereas guns can be bought at gun fairs without background checks and gun storage regulations are not subject to spot checks in the States.

Anyway, my principal excuse for this post is to present two editorial cartoons on gun control that I happened on during my research. They each sum up one aspect of the gun control debate. The first is a comment on the rationale of the Second Amendment.



The second is about the argument by gun advocates that what is needed is to keep guns out of the hands of mentally ill people. It points out that many of these gun advocates also oppose measures that would help mentally ill people.






I will end by citing Max Weber's definition of a state as an entity that holds a monopoly on the legitimate use of force. For a state to allow relatively unrestricted access to weapons undermines its legitimacy as a state, or so it seems to me. The same argument, but even more urgently, applies to a state that allows other organizations to set up private armies, such as mercenary organizations, private military companies (which are mercenaries under another name), and private militias, armed groups explicitly formed as a counter to state power.

Private military companies have several other problems associated with them. For example, though they may serve with American troops, they are not covered by the Geneva Convention and are not subject to military discipline and law. Such problems led to the maritime equivalent of private military companies, privateers, being banned by the Treaty of Paris. It is worth noting that the United States is not a signitory party to the treaty, though it abides by its terms.